Motivation, Function, and Behaviour Reinforcement: The Case of Loki

Loki, like many other dogs, doesn’t like being approached by strangers who enter his space and try to touch him.

Barking effusively (and sometimes lunging towards them) was one of the behaviours Loki adopted to keep them away.

All behaviours have a motivation (both endogenous and exogenous) and a function.

Given the behaviours mentioned, and considering that Loki is a dog with some insecurities who doesn’t feel comfortable around strangers and tends to be anxious in their presence, we can say that the function of his behaviour was to create distance between himself and the stranger (an aversive stimulus from Loki’s perspective).

In this context, the exogenous motivation behind his behaviour was tied to an attempt to restore his sense of security.

So, did it work?
The answer is simple: most of the time, yes!

This is related to learning, as well as to the exogenous and endogenous motivations for the behaviour.

Motivation, Function, and Behaviour Reinforcement: The Case of Loki

Loki learned that barking and lunging towards the stranger when they got too close (again, from his point of view) was an effective way to avoid or drive them away (exogenous motivation).

What did Loki feel when the stranger approached?

Given Loki’s history, most likely fear.

What did he feel when they moved away?

A profound sense of relief!

Here, we talk about both learning, the reinforcement history of the behaviour, and the endogenous motivation behind it.

Because these behaviours are linked to fear, and Loki succeeds when he exhibits them, the endogenous motivation and reinforcement for these behaviours are significant due to the release of dopamine (a neurotransmitter and hormone) in the brain and body, which predicts the release of opioids associated with the subsequent feeling of relief.

In the absence of other ways to deal with the approach of strangers, this was the quickest and most effective way for Loki to handle these situations.

Therefore, we worked on teaching Loki that it was possible to present alternative behaviours that would lead to the same outcome.

Motivation, Function, and Behaviour Reinforcement: The Case of Loki

We taught him that looking at his caregivers, instead of barking and lunging when he felt uncomfortable, was a way to escape the uncomfortable situation, gaining space and a reward. In this way, we reinforced the desired behaviour while simultaneously creating a positive association with strangers.

It’s important to note that Loki’s temperament, the lack of socialisation and environmental exposure during his early life, inadequate social and sensory stimulation, and possible adverse experiences during his first weeks of life in the shelter may have played a crucial role in the development of his fear of strangers.

This fear of strangers was exacerbated in the presence of a family member who, although not living in the same house as Loki, was part of the family and often visited.

Loki’s discomfort in their presence quickly escalated, becoming a stressful situation for everyone involved.

In this person’s presence, Loki exhibited behaviours such as effusive barking, avoidance, and flight, and after prolonged exposure, he showed signs of high stress and panic, such as trembling and prolonged withdrawal to places he considered safe. That is, hiding under the bed and refusing to come out while the person (the object of his fear) was present.

Looking at the function of Loki’s behaviour, we can easily see that it was tied to an attempt to increase the distance between himself and his “object of fear.”

Thus, the exogenous motivation was to restore security, with the endogenous motivational basis caused by the physiological and hormonal changes resulting from the activation of the brain areas responsible for the danger/threat detection response (Hypothalamus-Pituitary-Adrenal axis), leading to the release of adrenaline and cortisol (among others), known as the “stress hormones.”

As the “threat” remained and Loki couldn’t “get rid” of it, he fled, seeking refuge, with his body remaining in a constant state of alert, leading to high levels of anxiety and prolonged stress.

We, therefore, used desensitisation and counter-conditioning techniques, with an emphasis on classical conditioning, to gradually expose Loki to the conditioned negative stimulus (family member), in order to modify the conditioned emotional response (fear), building positive associations with their appearance and presence.

In the end, after a long process, these were the results:

“A week ago, my parents were here at home. Loki's ease in his behaviour was noticeable! Although they’re not best friends, he is clearly more comfortable. They ran together in the morning, and then he even sat next to them on the sofa.”

When we design an intervention plan, although focused on a particular problem, we end up seeing positive results in other areas because we work on the emotional state, allowing behaviours to generalise.

“Today, some friends came over with their little boy. The difference in Loki's behaviour is enormous!”

Thank you to Loki's family for your trust, and thank you, Loki, for trusting me and allowing me to learn from you. Congratulations to all of you.

References:

Lindsay, Steven (2000) Handbook of Applied Dog Behavior and Training: Adaptation and Learning, (Vol. 1) 1st Edition. Blackwell Publishing, Iowa State University Press.

Lindsay, Steven (2001) Handbook of Applied Dog Behavior and Training: Etiology and Assessment of Behavior Problems (Vol. 2) 1st Edition. Blackwell Publishing, Iowa State University Press.

Lindsay, Steven (2005) Handbook of Applied Dog Behavior and Training: Procedures and Protocols (Vol. 3) 1st Edition. Blackwell Publishing, Iowa, United States of America.

O’Heare, J. (2005) Canine Neuropsychology 3rd edition. BehaveTech Publishing, Ottawa, Canada.

Overall, Karen (2013). Manual of Clinical Behavioral Medicine for Dogs and Cats - E-Book. Elsevier Health Sciences. Kindle Edition.

Panksepp, J. & Biven, L. (2012) The Archaeology of Mind: 1st Edition. MidAtlantic Publishing Services, United States of America.

Scholz, M. & Reinhardt, C. (2007) Stress in Dogs. Dogwise Publishing, Wenatchee, Washington, United States of America.

NEWSLETTER

Sign up to receive our news in your email and get access to a free basic trainning e-book.

By subscribing to our newsletter, you agree to the processing of personal data in accordance with the Privacy and Data Protection Policy.

Copyright DogAware © 2023.

All rights reserved